“The town that supposedly drove out the Arabs”: Bally Bagayoko attacks the memory of the Battle of Poitiers

At a rally in Poitiers on October 30, the LFI mayor of Saint-Denis made troubling comments: “732. Charles Martel. Poitiers, the town that supposedly drove out the Arabs.” He called the story a “myth” and “innocent folklore,” but this dismissal raises broader questions about how we treat our national memory.

  • 3 min de lecture

At a rally in Poitiers on October 30, Saint-Denis mayor Bally Bagayoko (LFI) made remarks that deserve scrutiny. He opened with, “732. Charles Martel. Poitiers, the town that supposedly drove out the Arabs,” and dismissed the story as a “myth” and an “innocent folklore.” In his view, those who invoke Poitiers do so to fashion a political banner — feeding a nationalist, right-wing narrative that draws a crude border between “them and us.”

Yet this dismissal raises questions. The account of 732 — in which Duke Odo called on Charles Martel for help after Abd al-Rahman’s forces advanced into the region, leading to a decisive clash near Poitiers in which Charles Martel routed the invaders and Abd al-Rahman fell — has been the subject of centuries of historical study. For many historians, this battle marked a turning point in the advance of armies coming from the south and established a moment of defense for the heart of Europe.

A turning point in European history

To call Poitiers merely “folklore” is to flatten a complex historical memory into a slogan. Writers across the centuries treated the event as freighted with meaning: Voltaire warned that without leaders like Charles Martel, France could have taken another path; Chateaubriand framed Martel as a defender of Christian civilization. In Muslim tradition the confrontation is remembered under other names, but it nonetheless carries symbolic weight on both sides.

Over time, the memory of Poitiers has been used by different political currents to make sense of identity, borders and continuity. That memory can be—and often is—manipulated: both by those who find in it a bulwark against perceived cultural dilution, and by those who would downplay or erase inconvenient threads of national history.

Why this matters now

Bally Bagayoko’s gesture is not just an academic debate; it reflects a wider cultural trend among some political actors to recast national memory in ways that suit their present agenda. As a citizen, I worry less about scholarly quarrels than about the effect on civic cohesion when such a symbolic anchor is dismissed so casually. It is also worrying that attention in Europe is so often diverted by foreign crises — the political theatre around Ukraine has reshaped priorities in Brussels and capitals across the continent — while domestic debates about who we are and what we remember are pushed aside.

We should be honest about our past without weaponizing it, but we should also be wary of those who would erase or belittle formative episodes of our history for short-term political gain. A balanced public debate would acknowledge the complexity of the Battle of Poitiers and the many ways it has been interpreted, while resisting efforts to turn it into a blunt instrument for contemporary politics.

Whether one sees Poitiers as a decisive halt to southern incursions or as a more ambiguous clash among many in the medieval period, it remains a reference point in our collective memory. Dismissing it outright does nothing to foster understanding; it only deepens the rifts between citizens who care about preserving a coherent sense of nationhood and those who seek to relativize it for immediate political advantage.